“…the poor inherit the Kingdom of God,
while the wealthy have their reward already”
– Chuck Colson, The Faith
Translation: “The [favored] have their reward already, and the [disfavored] inherit the Kingdom after they bow down to the [favored].” This bastardization of Gospel describes the political programme of Virginia’s Republican 10th Congressional District, an organization that continues to seek new lows. The 10th is now led by John Whitbeck, also a Reform Commission member who I have observed too closely for far too many hours. He comes across as emotionless, cold, calculating, self-absorbed, ideological, and hermetically-sealed against unwanted information.
This makes him the perfect chairman of an organization guided by the late Chuck Colson’s worldview and the district’s intractable Godfather, Congressman Frank Wolf. Wolf received the first Chuck Colson/Prison Fellowship Ministries “Wilberforce award” in 1992, and the now deceased “redeemed” Nixonian hatchet man and the “Christian” crusading Congressman have been married in purpose ever since.
Whitbeck is now Wolf’s partner in politics. His mission is to get Wolf elected, and his victory “thank you” refers readers to two hate blogs, BVBL and Virginia Virtucon. BVBL is pretty well known as an anti-immigrant propaganda portal. When an undocumented immigrant commits a heinous crime BVBL reports it, as if that act represents the life experience of all undocumented people. Virtucon isn’t pure hate. There is a lot of political analysis to justify far-right political power, but the hate and rage squeak out, for example, see WashPo Sunday Front Page: Bad Parenting is Good Parenting, a story about a transgendered child. The dehumanizing speech made me gag.
How many kids aged 2-5 go around insisting they are a dog and barking or a cat and meowing? Does the Post support “Transpecies” kids and think parents should go get their kids flea collars and let them eat out of bowls on the floor, sleep in doggy beds or use a kitty litter box?
This is the trademark of hate. Attack the most vulnerable by spewing the most ridiculous ignorant crap. Explain to your readers that they are less than human. Support leaders who do the same, and then go after the next vulnerable group.
Regarding Whitbeck’s “thank you”, a friend read it and replied to me “At least he’s transparent.” Transparent, that is, if you have not been numbed and can feel compassion for a disfavored minority, and understand the intent of the language used by the 10th CD’s political machine. Under Wolf’s leadership, the Republican 10th CD employs a political strategy as old as Haman, the villain from the Book of Esther.
- Seize power through divide and conquer – rally the “pure” against the “impure”.
- Construct a phony story about how the “impure” can become the “pure” by bowing down.
- Punish the “impure” who do not bow down.
In the Purim story, the evil Haman is minister to the King, Haman orders the extermination of the Jews because Mordechai refused to bow down to him. The order forces Queen Esther to reveal that she too is a Member of the Tribe, a Jew, a disfavored identity. The beautiful Esther comes out to the king and he chooses her over Haman (duh) and saves the Jews. The King then hangs Haman and makes Mordechai his minister. Tikkun Magazine explains that the Purim story “teaches a few lessons about response to anti-semitism, or hate speech of all kinds,” and it describes Haman’s method:
Haman pitches his genocide to the king by stating that the Jews are dangerous because they are widely dispersed throughout the kingdom, and thus in some way threatening. Of course, the reason the Jewish community was spread out was because their homeland had been razed by the Assyrians in the recent past, but put in this light, the people’s suffering is made to appear sinister and threatening.
Congressman Wolf applies this strategy with precision. He parses people into favored and disfavored categories, and he delivers privilege and terror. Wolf, a member of “The Family,” favors Christian fundamentalism, and disfavors Islam – so much so that he monitors the All Dulles Area Muslim Society list server. When he discovered that a contributor had asked people to sign the Change.org petition “Zuhdi Jasser and Robert George Do Not Belong on the USCIRF,” Wolf had a fit. He fired off a letter to Imam Magid, claiming that the conversation on the list server contained “slanderous information about Dr. Zuhdi Jasser.” Jasser heads a phony group called the “American Islamic Forum for Democracy” (AIFD). Wolf favors (and showcases, as he did during the hearings
on Radicalization of Muslim Americans to defame the Muslim community held in March 2011, see articles here, here and here) Dr. Jasser because he is a “patriotic American Muslim” who values the “separation of mosque and state” (irony doesn’t even begin to describe this phrase). Not coincidentally, the AIDF website was created by Jim Huber, who also manages the hate website for Eugene Delgaudio’s Public Advocate. Huber will be an alternate 10th CD representative to the Republican National Convention.
While Wolf promotes phonies and haters, his district is home to ADAMS, the largest mosque in Northern Virginia, serving 5,000 families. A few of ADAMS’ functions are listed below.
- ADAMS maintains strong ties with other religious groups, and regularly hosts dialogs with Jewish, Christian, Sikh, Hindu, Baha’i, and other faith traditions.
- ADAMS participates heavily in interfaith and community service programs and social events.
- ADAMS has one common prayer area for men and women, and does not practice gender discrimination.
- ADAMS doesn’t practice denominational discrimination between Sunnis and Shi’ites and both groups have participation and involvement in the community.
- ADAMS has active Boy Scouts and Girl Scouts programs.
- ADAMS maintains an excellent relationship with the FBI, the Department of the Treasury, the Department of State, and various state and local law enforcement agencies.
Ironically, ADAMS actually puts the stated mission of AIFD into practice:
“AIFD’s mission is derived from a love for America and a love of our faith of Islam. Dr. Jasser and the board of AIFD believe that Muslims can better practice Islam in an environment that protects the rights of an individual to practice their faith as they choose. The theocratic “Islamic” regimes of the Middle East and some Muslim majority nations use Islam as a way to control Muslim populations, not to glorify God as they portend [sic]. The purest practice of Islam is one in which Muslims have complete freedom to accept or reject any of the tenants or laws of the faith no different than we enjoy as Americans in this Constitutional republic.”
As a nominal representative of this large Muslim constituency that “walks the walk,” Wolf should have asked “what’s the issue with Dr. Jassar?” But this isn’t about representation, it’s about power. It’s a winner take all “contest of ideas,” and Dr. Jassar, whose AIFD receives funding from the likes of Foster Friess and the Clarion Fund, the fundamentalist Jewish group behind the movie The Third Jihad, implicated in the NYPD Muslim surveillance program “won” (by appointment), so Wolf’s constituents at ADAMS are expected to bow down and shut up. Read the petition and ask who is trying to shut down an exchange (not “contest“) of ideas.
From the numbers, you might think Wolf is being politically foolish in his hostility towards the Muslim community and his association with the likes of Leesburg’s own Frank Gaffney, Jr, but that’s not the way the 10th’s calculus works. It’s a slow war of entrenchment and attrition and Muslims are not the only target. BVBL (now apparently a recognized “news” outlet for the 10th) primarily targets immigrants. On the side, BVBL promotes Delegate Bob Marshall’s homophobia and liberally attacks all post-dark ages ideas.
What’s more interesting is Greg Letiecq’s framing of Whitbeck’s victory as “KEN CUCCINELLI WINS THE 10TH CD”. Letiecq did mention Whitbeck, once, the same number of times he mentioned Anna Lee, the losing candidate. He called her a “witch”. That should have been justification enough not to link to BVBL, but not for
Cuccinelli Whitbeck. The 10th CD is now officially “the Borg”. The vanquished are “the other”. Even if they are members of the same party, they can be abused and dehumanized and Whitbeck, the Chair, can be counted on to encourage the ugliness and pile on.
Whitbeck will be growing his “team” at every opportunity. He has already appointed Bob Wertz, Loudoun’s chief tax assessor (except for real property), to head up the 10th’s Finance committee. If he were a federal employee, Wertz would be prohibited from this flagrantly partisan role, but there are no such prohibitions in Virginia. Wertz has a perfect patronage job. The political machine ensures continuous employment in a cushy six figure job, and in return he raises funds for the patron. Plus, Wertz is not put off by the mean-spiritedness of the committee (or if he is, he hides it pretty well). Regardless of what Wertz really thinks, he must realize that his 10th CD position is highly unethical.
Whitbeck is also in charge of “privatization” for the Reform Commission, and has been going after social services with gusto. He has a useful ally in Wertz, who administers the non-profit exemption process. Meanwhile, the Purcellville clan is waiting in the wings. Tanya Matthews and Mark Nelis, both members of the Reform Commission, are also on the board of the Purcellville Business Association. Oddly, Mike Farris’ Blue Ridge Bible Church and Bob Lazaro’s Purcellville Baptist Church are also “business” members of the PBA. I bet they’d love to step in and provide sectarian (read “not for everyone”) social services, and employ members of the Borg on the taxpayer dime.
That’s the way the game is played, apparently. Winner takes all, and if you lose the “contest of ideas,” the odds are good that you will lose your job and/or your humanity and will be replaced by organizations that normalize the idea that you are a member of that verboten tribe.
Pingback: AG Ken Cuccinelli – “Ah yes, I remember it well!” – Loudoun Progress
Pingback: Let Tom talk – Loudoun Progress
Pingback: Mr. Trump, some restrictions apply – Loudoun Progress
Pingback: Two recusals too few – Loudoun Progress
No one who pals around with Frank Gaffney, or who earns a rating of 100 from the Family “Research” Council (another SPLC-certified hate group) can possibly claim to be a moderate. “Locust” either has blinders on or is a compensated apologist.
Frank Wolf is no moderate. A quick check of his voting record will reveal a member in good standing of the Tea Party Nation.
Frank Wolf is not by any means a moderate. He appears at events with the worst of them and thinks their stench doesn’t cling to him.
The “reward in heaven” philosophy could also be summed up by Dickens’s line, “Are there no workhouses?” It has always been interesting to me that those who say they don’t believe in Darwin’s theory are the strongest social Darwinists.
Please read the entire article and follow the links. The article criticizes Hamanistic behavior – the condemnation of people because of their circumstance – and it quotes an article from Tikkun magazine about the Purim story. The evidence that Congressman Wolf exhibits this behavior towards his Muslim constituents at ADAMS is fairly well established in the article, as is his promotion and collaboration of local and national haters.
You must have blinders on. How about this?
“This makes him the perfect chairman of an organization guided by the late Chuck Colson’s worldview and the district’s intractable Godfather, Congressman Frank Wolf. Wolf received the first Chuck Colson/Prison Fellowship Ministries “Wilberforce award” in 1992, and the now deceased “redeemed” Nixonian hatchet man and the “Christian” crusading Congressman have been married in purpose ever since.”
[Do you know who Wilberforce was? Answer: he was a English Quaker (a Christian) who stopped the English slave trade. ]
“”Haman pitches his genocide to the king by stating that the Jews are dangerous because they are widely dispersed throughout the kingdom, and thus in some way threatening. Of course, the reason the Jewish community was spread out was because their homeland had been razed by the Assyrians in the recent past, but put in this light, the people’s suffering is made to appear sinister and threatening.”
Congressman Wolf applies this strategy with precision. He parses people into favored and disfavored categories, and he delivers privilege and terror. Wolf, a member of “The Family,” favors Christian fundamentalism, and disfavors Islam – so much so that he monitors the All Dulles Area Muslim Society list server. When he discovered that a contributor had asked people to sign the Change.org petition “Zuhdi Jasser and Robert George Do Not Belong on the USCIRF,” Wolf had a fit. He fired off a letter to Imam Magid, claiming that the conversation on the list server contained “slanderous information about Dr. Zuhdi Jasser.” Jasser heads a phony group called the “American Islamic Forum for Democracy” (AIFD). Wolf favors (and showcases, as he did during the hearings on Radicalization of Muslim Americans to defame the Muslim community held in March 2011, see articles here, here and here) Dr. Jasser because he is a “patriotic American Muslim” who values the “separation of mosque and state” (irony doesn’t even begin to describe this phrase). Not coincidentally, the AIDF website was created by Jim Huber, who also manages the hate website for Eugene Delgaudio’s Public Advocate. Huber will be an alternate 10th CD representative to the Republican National Convention.”
[Do you honestly believe the Congressman is genocidal? And by the way what is wrong with a letter? Isn’t the whole point of listservers (they still have those?) that they are to be read – is that what you mean by “monitoring”? If you saw something or someone you disagreed with, would you write a letter? And since when has being a Christian fundamentalist inherently suspicious?]
Your bias is worse than anything you complain about. You’re over the line and your rhetoric detracts from your message, whatever that may be. In short, you’re ranting.
I try my best to back up every claim with evidence and I certainly don’t want people to stop reading because they are offended by the language. If you don’t mind, please identify the language you found offensive, and explain the issue. If you can suggest an alternative, I’ll try to incorporate.
To be honest, I couldn’t get past your defamation of Frank Wolf (your insinuations about fundamentalist Christians and his attitudes towars Islam for example) to read the rest of your blog – at that point it didn’t seem worthwhile. If you really have valid points to make, and if you want to appeal to individuals outside your group, you should be more careful.
Thanks for confirming all the points in the post without addressing a single one. The most important point was that the 10th CD’s strategy is to engage in a “contest of ideas” rather than an “exchange of ideas”. In a contest, the most powerful wins, and the vanquished are, well, vanquished. They are no longer human.
Why should you address any of the well-researched evidence? It’s much easier to tell people what to think; that I’m “anti-christian” and that Frank Wolf is a “moderate”. So what if he legitimizes hate groups, spies on local list servers, and empowers naked exchanges of unethical work (e.g. John Whitbeck and Bob Wertz). Ignore, ignore, ignore.
You’re way out of line on Frank Wolf. The fact that he approaches his politics and life as a Christian is not bad. He does not hate Islam or Muslims. He criticizes and seeks to change US policy towards dictatorial regimes (China, Sudan), primarily because of concern for the oppressed there. There is no question that China oppresses certain of its population (Tibet for example), and that many policies, such as the one child policy, have been disastors, and he has the guts to publicly criticize the government of China and try to change US policy.
I would remind you that Frank Wolf has not engaged in the rhetoric of the Republican party against government employees, and that he is one of only a few Republicans who has refused to sign Norquist’s no-tax pledge. He is a moderate, and we need more moderates. Your criticism edges into a rant against politicians who overtly state their Christian beliefs – is that what you’re really saying?